Soap Stars Who Will Never Make A Comeback

Published on July 20, 2017. Updated August 23, 2022

The land of daytime drama is like a revolving door. One minute you may see your favorite actor or actress on Days of Our Lives (DOOL) and within a couple of weeks, they may be off to General Hospital (GH), Young and the Restless (Y&R), or Bold and the Beautiful (B&B). The reality is, while some soap stars become staples of their respective shows, there are times when they move around, try different parts and don’t necessarily come back! Below are soap stars who are unlikely to make a comeback in the soap industry.

Want soap spoilers delivered to your inbox every week? Sign up for Fame10’s weekly soap opera spoilers newsletter.

8. James Scott

They say, ‘never say never’, but James Scott (who played EJ DiMera from 2006 to 2014) can’t say it enough! When asked by a fan whether he’d ever return to DOOL, the former actor put it plainly. “Please know that I will never. Never. Never. Never. Never. Go back to Hollywood let alone DOOL,” Scott insisted. “There is nothing interesting for me.” The NBC soap clearly got the message and later recast the character with Dan Feuerriegel, who is doing great things in the role. At least Scott was very clear about his position!

© Howard Wise/jpistudios.com

7. Jessica Collins

Y&R fans miss the smart and beautiful Avery Clark, played by the incredibly talented Jessica Collins. Collins exited the role in 2015 and gave birth to a beautiful bouncy baby girl in early 2016. One sneak peek at Collins’ Instagram account and it is clear: The actress is enjoying motherhood immensely. To boot, Collins has a love of the culinary arts and is an incredible chef and food writer, two activities that also keep her busy. Could she return to the land of soaps? Anything is possible, but it seems like Collins is quite content with the list of things on her plate right now.

© Howard Wise/jpistudios.com

6. Tony Geary

Tony Geary built an incredible soap opera legacy portraying the infamous Luke Spencer on GH. After decades on the show and racking up a record-setting eight Daytime Emmys, Geary called it quits in 2015 and blamed his early retirement on being “weary” of the grind. It seems he is enjoying retirement and the life away from a busy soap schedule. While he did return to GH to help bid Jane Elliott’s Tracy Quartermaine character adieu, the idea of Geary coming out of retirement to return to the soap is very unlikely. And it appeared all the more final in early 2022 when GH announced that Luke had perished in Austria under mysterious circumstances.

© Jill Johnson/jpistudios.com

5. Susan Flannery

Speaking of retirement, B&B fans were devastated when Susan Flannery decided to leave the show behind in 2012, marking the end of an era as her character Stephanie Forrester passed away. While her demise was final, no character is ever really gone in the land of soaps! A Flannery comeback is unlikely, and this has more to do with the fact that she seems to be enjoying retirement too much to return to daytime drama. During a 2013 interview with TV Guide, she was asked if she missed B&B and simply replied with a “nope.”

©John Paschal/jpistudios.com

4. Ronn Moss

B&B fans lost Susan Flannery and fan-favorite Ronn Moss within months of each other back in 2012. While his Ridge Forrester role was recast with Thorsten Kaye, some B&B fans still think of Moss when it comes to this part. He seems to be enjoying the open road, touring and playing music with his band. Moss and the band was even showcased during GH’s 2014 Nurse’s Ball event where they played “Baby Come Back.” While he clearly enjoyed the land of soaps, Moss may just like playing music a little more.

© Jill Johnson/jpistudios.com

3. Renée Jones

Renée Jones played DOOL’s Lexie Carver for well over two decades after taking the role on in 1993. Lexie was a good person, who at times made bad decisions, but overall, a Days‘ fan-favorite. In 2012, Jones sadly confirmed she would be leaving the show to retire. According to a TV Guide interview, she yearned for a simpler life and was not happy with acting anymore.

© Jill Johnson/jpistudios.com

2. Ingo Rademacher

Even popular talents can wind up polarizing their audience. The Aussie actor, who is primarily known for his decades-long portrayal of Jax on GH, also won over fans on B&B as Thorne. Yet his stance on ABC’s health mandate — while valid as a personal belief — created a ton of drama for GH. He got into a nasty war of words with co-star Nancy Lee Grahn and sued his former workplace. Compared to the respectful way Steve Burton left the soap over the same mandate, Rademacher’s handling of the issue might be a serious drawback to getting future work in daytime drama.

© XJJohnson/jpistudios.com

1. Victoria Rowell

Anyone else miss Y&R’s Drucilla Winters? Well, the character could always return, but perhaps not being portrayed by Victoria Rowell. Back in 2015, she launched a legal suit against the soap, Sony Pictures, and CBS, reporting racial discrimination. Rowell also had her fair share of issues with Y&R co-stars over the years, including an alleged rivalry with Michelle Stafford (Phyllis Summers) and a Twitter war of words with Eileen Davidson (Ashley Abbott) in 2015. A Y&R comeback does not seem likely for this actress.

©Aaron Montgomery/JPI

Soap Opera Stars Who Haven’t Aged

Soap Operas

Soap Opera Stars Who Haven’t Aged

X
- Click Here to Close Menu -